
The top director in Telugu cinema heard Ram Gopal Varma’s story and said it sounded experimental, with no drama. The story was Shiva.
RGV, not yet a director, had been asked to narrate it to K. Raghavendra Rao, who ruled Telugu cinema in the 1980s. While reworking the script, he happened to watch Rao’s Kaliyuga Pandavulu and understood how Shiva looked from where Rao stood. He gave up the idea, albeit briefly.
When Shiva (1989) was released, the first report from the theatres was unsettling. The audience was watching without any reaction. The team didn’t know what to make of it, until they eventually found out the reason: people were stunned. The film went on to inspire a new crop of directors to narrate offbeat stories in a commercial format.
Rao’s reading was valid by the standards of the films he made. The idea didn’t change. What changed was that RGV didn’t stay discouraged for long.
Same story, different storytelling
Persisting with the idea wasn’t enough, though. The craft had to catch up.
I wrote earlier about two of RGV’s films, Satya and Antham. Their plots are the same: a ruthless criminal meets a girl, falls in love, tries to renounce his profession, but karma catches up with him. Yet only one of them became a landmark.
What changed? It was specificity, causation that pushed every scene into the next, and small details that revealed characters. That kind of discernment comes only from practice, and a lot of it. In the beginning, most writers (and filmmakers) feel their vision is compelling enough to stand on its own. Over the years, they realize nothing is new under the sun. What made the greats great was how they communicated the vision.
There was an Antham before there was a Satya. The person who made the second film had to emerge from the person who made the first.
The shortcut that proved fatal
There’s a story in the Mahabharata I keep returning to. Yavakrida wanted to be a great scholar without studying. He performed penance, and Indra eventually yielded and granted him the boon. Yavakrida became learned, but also haughty and impetuous, because he had leaped over the path without traversing it. His father had warned him: the gods grant such boons to fools, much like intoxicants are sold to them. It didn’t end well for him.
Shortcuts fail because it’s the path that prepares you for the destination. Nietzsche said as much: “A man has no ears for that to which experience has given him no access.” If success were handed over early, we’d lack the ears for it.
This is also why overnight success is slightly misleading. The overnight part is what the audience sees. The years of poor drafts, quiet failures and re-edits are invisible, so it appears as though a nobody turned into somebody.
Nobody was a nobody. Some people were simply at an earlier station in the same line.
None of this means every unit of effort pays equally. The first re-edit of an article yields rich results, the third much less. Yet a writer who never does the first never reaches the third. Persistence is about improving the odds that your material finds its moment.
The part that’s hard to say
It’s hard to practice persistence when you’ve toiled for years without success. It’s harder still when people you started alongside, or even those who started after you, have raced ahead.
A good part of success is the right time and the right place.
The path doesn’t guarantee the arrival. But without it, the arrival has nothing to land on.
And if luck is part of the story, we can’t summon it to arrive sooner. All we can do is manage it by staying in the game. As Scott Adams said: Systems > Goals.
For me, staying in the game is a system. I write even when I’m not inspired, because work inspires inspiration. I bleed words until the story coalesces into something that makes sense on its own. Clarity comes from action, not before it.
I also maintain a commonplace book. Every idea that interests me goes into it, so on the days nothing comes, I don’t have to stare at a wall. I pick whichever idea appeals to me and expand on it. When an angle emerges that ties a few ideas together, I record it before it slips away. Sometimes the angle is a cliché and gets discarded. Often, it works.
It’s a way of averting writer’s block by parking ideas downhill, where it’s easier to travel.
Nobody is a nobody
The opening anecdote stays with me. The first response to Shiva wasn’t applause. It was silence.
Sometimes the response to years of work is silence before it’s anything else. From the inside, it’s hard to tell which kind you’re in: an audience that’s unmoved, or one that’s stunned. All we can do is keep making the thing, and let the audience catch up.
Nobody is a nobody. Some of us are just still in the silence.
P.S. It’s Vijayadashami today, so one more thought. Ravana had carried off women before, but he (largely) didn’t pay for it. His abduction of Sita was just one more instance of a pattern he had long held. What the pattern couldn’t predict was Rama: exiled, with no army except the allies he won along the way, who would find Sita, cross the sea and keep braving grave injuries and disappointments. The epic is about far more than persistence. But in this one thread, Ravana’s mistake was assuming that what had no precedent would never get one. In not accounting for someone like Rama, who persisted against all odds, until he achieved what no one could before.
Leave a Reply